COP26 – Greenhouse Gas Emissions

No one could have avoided coverage of the COP26 conference in Glasgow and the constant pressure that agriculture is now facing to reduce its contribution to greenhouse gas emissions.

The place to start is to understand just what it all means and the science behind it.

Greenhouse gases (GHG) namely carbon dioxide (C02), methane (CH4), and nitrous oxide (N20) are gases that are emitted and exist in our atmosphere and are responsible for the so called ‘greenhouse effect’, the trapping of energy from the sun’s rays in our atmosphere and the resultant heating of the planet. Agriculture is responsible for 10% of the UK’s greenhouse gas emissions.

Carbon dioxide is the most common GHG globally so often nitrous oxide and methane are reported as ‘CO2 equivalents’ (CO2e). For example, you may hear figures reported that a kg of beef has a C02e of 15.8 tonnes – this takes into account all three greenhouse gases.

In agriculture methane and nitrous oxide make up the largest proportion of emissions, 50% and 40% respectively. Carbon dioxide contributes just 10%. Each gas behaves differently and contributes differently to global warming. The Global Warming Potential (GWP) is a figure attributed to a gas depending on how much energy it holds in the atmosphere compared to CO2.

CO2 remains in the atmosphere for hundreds of years – it is a ‘stock gas’, it accumulates. The emissions from the car journey you make today will be having an effect for generations to come. CO2 is used as the baseline for the other gases to be compared against so CO2 has a GWP of 1.

Carbon dioxide is emitted from any fuel usage be that heating, cooling, vehicles, machinery etc. The disruption of farmland e.g. ploughing also releases carbon dioxide. Conversely, the removal of carbon dioxide from the atmosphere is called carbon sequestration or carbon fixing (this is part of the classically taught ‘Carbon Cycle’ where carbon goes back into the ground or water). Agriculture involving the change of use of natural land affects carbon sequestration, for example destroying peat bogs or woodland reduces the amount of carbon removed from the atmosphere .

Nitrous oxide has the ability to hold a lot of energy in the atmosphere and is far more harmful than CO2; it has a GWP of 265-298 and it lasts in the atmosphere for 100 years. This is the gas that is the most damaging and it is here we need to work hard to reduce its emission.

Nitrous oxide comes from fertilising land either with slurry, muck or fertiliser – intensively farmed land emits more nitrous oxide. The method and timings of applications and the weather affect these emissions

Methane has a GWP of 28, not quite so bad, and it only lasts in the atmosphere for approximately 12 years – relatively short lived. There is controversy over the stated GWP of methane given its short lifespan; methane is constantly being removed from the atmosphere so is not really that bad.

Plants use CO2 to grow and do so by the process of photosynthesis. Cows eat plants. Cows belch methane. Methane eventually breaks down into water and CO2. CO2 then gets synthesised back into the plant. With this perspective and the timings involved there is a reasonable argument that methane production is not as bad as is being made out.

If the amount produced and amount removed are in equilibrium there will be no warming, if there is more removed than produced there will actually be a cooling effect!

This recycling of methane is not accounted for in GWP100 figures. It is now proposed that the new measure, GWP*, replaces the GWP100 measure so as to account for the different life spans of the three GHGs in the atmosphere. As methane is the main GHG contribution of agriculture this will make a big difference to how agriculture is perceived in its contribution to global warming.

Methane is the focus of much climate change policy because it’s a quick (temporary) fix. Reducing methane will quickly reduce the rate that global temperatures rise while the world sorts out what it’s going to do about carbon dioxide, much the bigger problem. It would only take a 100-cow herd to achieve a 0.3% reduction in methane emission every year for 20 years for that herd to become carbon neutral.

Methane exists mainly in cow burps or belch (with only a little occurring in their farts!) – these emissions correctly known as enteric emissions if you’re minding your Ps and Qs! For beef and sheep this is the biggest contribution to GHG emissions. The type of livestock, the feed, and the genetics all affect methane enteric emissions. Emissions other than enteric do occur: slurry/manure stored with no oxygenation generates quite a lot of methane, more than, as it happens, slurry that is not stored but instead spread daily.

There are various opinions and discussions over how GHGs are measured, here are just a few…

There is a large amount of variability in the carbon calculators used across the industry. One of the variabilities is how they account for carbon sequestration. For example – the industry has suggested that improving food conversion efficiency (FCE) and daily liveweight gain (DLWG) is the best way forward to drive down emissions. The hill sheep or cow eating low energy density, low digestibility grass produces more methane and takes longer to get fat than a lamb or beast on a lowland lush green pasture that fattens quickly. The hill farmers would argue that that hill with massive amounts of naturally occurring organic matter and peat bogs is sequestering huge amounts of carbon which off sets the high enteric emission of the stock it grazes and offer the challenge that there is a carbon cost to the relatively unnatural feed that is used to achieve high DLWG, be that improved pasture or farmed concentrate.

Suckler beef gets a hard time compared to dairy beef. The carbon cost of the dairy cow is tagged to her milk production, the calf is a by-product. The beef calf from the dairy herd starts its life at net 0, in contrast to the suckler herd where the entire carbon cost of the cow is burdened by the calf. It’s even worse in reality; if we are only selling 80 calves per 100 cows, the 85 cows take the carbon cost of all 100 cows, 1.25 cows allocated to each calf.

From a veterinary point of view, while the ‘powers-that-be’ argue over how these things should be measured, we can focus on getting the basics right. Reducing the number of barren cows, achieving compact calving periods, minimising cow and calf mortality, sorting out parasite and trace element issues to improve growth rates and feed conversion efficiency, reducing replacement rates, calving heifers at a younger age etc. There is a huge amount of wastage and there is always room for improvement. Doing the basics better will also make the enterprise more profitable – a win-win.

We would encourage you all to take a look at the Farm Carbon Toolkit website. This is a free service and you can carry out your own carbon audit. This carbon calculator makes allowances for land type and the different carbon sequestration rates of different types of land. It also uses GWP* which favours agricultural businesses for the reasons stated above. We are more than happy to answer any questions and help with your carbon audit, just get in touch.

Contact Us

01434 239444

Address

The Fold Farm Vets Ltd – Tyne Green – Hexham Northumberland – NE46 3SG

Share this post